Wood Burning vs Propane Fire Pits
Compare wood burning and propane fire pits across cost, convenience, heat output, ambiance, and maintenance. Find out which fuel type fits your lifestyle.
ProductPickly is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks.
Tiki Brand Smokeless Patio Fire Pit
A wood burning smokeless pit that delivers real campfire ambiance with less smoke and high heat output.
Check priceOutland Living Fire Table 400
A propane fire table with instant ignition, adjustable heat, and clean operation. Ideal for patios and balconies.
Check priceIf you love the crackle, the smell, and the ritual of tending a fire, choose wood. If you want instant heat, zero cleanup, and safe use on a deck, choose propane.
Spec by spec
Highlighted cell wins that row.
| Tiki Brand Smokeless Patio Fire Pit | Outland Living Fire Table 400 | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel type | Wood logs | Propane tank |
| Heat output | Up to 40,000 BTU (varies) | 40,000 BTU |
| Ignition | Manual, requires lighter | Push-button electronic |
| Smoke | Minimal with smokeless design | None |
| Maintenance | Ash cleanup, chimney cleaning | Occasional tank refill |
| Fuel cost per hour | Variable, often cheaper | Higher, but consistent |
| Portability | Heavy, but no tank | Light, but needs tank |
Who should buy which
- + You love the authentic crackle and aroma of real wood.
- + You have a ready supply of firewood or want to forage.
- + You enjoy the hands-on ritual of building and tending a fire.
- + You want instant fire at the push of a button.
- + You live in an apartment, condo, or have a small patio.
- + You dislike ash, smoke, and post-fire cleanup.
Quick questions
Which fire pit is cheaper to run, wood or propane?
Wood is generally cheaper per hour, especially if you source free or low-cost firewood. Propane costs more per hour, but you pay for convenience and zero cleanup.
Can I use a propane fire pit on a wooden deck?
Yes, propane fire pits are safe on decks as long as they are placed on a non-combustible surface and follow the manufacturer's clearance guidelines. Wood burning pits are not recommended on wood decks due to sparks and embers.
Which fire pit produces more heat?
Both can produce similar heat output, typically around 40,000 BTU. However, wood pits can sometimes generate more radiant heat, but it's less consistent. Propane offers steady, adjustable heat.