Wire vs Plastic Dog Crates: Which Is Better?
Wire crates offer superior ventilation and visibility, while plastic crates provide more privacy and security for anxious dogs. Our editorial team compared specifications, buyer feedback and key decision factors to help you choose the right crate for your home, travel and training needs.
ProductPickly is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks.
MidWest LifeStages Double Door Wire Dog Crate
A versatile wire crate with excellent airflow, two doors for flexibility, and a durable construction that folds flat for storage. Ideal for home use and crate training.
Check pricePetmate Two Door Top Load Plastic Dog Kennel
A sturdy plastic kennel with top and front doors, designed for travel, airline use, and dogs that prefer a cozy, den-like environment. Offers more privacy and security.
Check priceIf you need a crate for everyday home use, training, or a dog that values airflow and visibility, go with the wire crate. If you travel frequently, need airline approval, or have an anxious dog that craves a secure den, the plastic crate is your best bet. Both are excellent, but the wire crate wins for overall versatility.
Spec by spec
Highlighted cell wins that row.
| MidWest LifeStages Double Door Wire Dog Crate | Petmate Two Door Top Load Plastic Dog Kennel | |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | Strong welded wire, chew-resistant, but can bend with extreme force | High-impact plastic, resists bites and scratches, but can crack under heavy impact |
| Ventilation | Open wire mesh, maximum airflow and visibility | Limited windows, less airflow, can get hot in warm climates |
| Portability | Folds flat for storage, heavier than plastic, no handle | Lightweight with handle, airline approved, easy to carry |
| Safety | Open design may allow dogs to stick paws out, risk of injury | Enclosed design prevents paw sticking, more secure for travel |
| Suitability for anxious dogs | Less privacy, may increase anxiety for some dogs | Den-like feel, blocks visual stimuli, calms anxious dogs |
| Cleaning | Easy to wipe down, but urine can leak through wire floor | Solid pan catches messes, easy to remove and clean |
| Price | Generally more affordable for larger sizes | Often more expensive for quality plastic crates |
Who should buy which
- + Crate training a new puppy or dog at home
- + Dogs that need good airflow in warm climates
- + Owners who want a crate that folds flat for storage
- + Dogs that like to see their surroundings
- + Frequent travelers or those needing airline-approved crates
- + Anxious dogs that prefer a cozy, den-like space
- + Owners who need a lightweight, portable crate
- + Dogs that might stick paws out of wire crates
Quick questions
Are plastic dog crates safe for airline travel?
Yes, many plastic dog crates are specifically designed to meet airline requirements. Look for crates that are IATA-approved, with proper ventilation, a secure latch, and a leak-proof bottom. Always check with your airline for specific size and material requirements before flying.
Can I use a wire crate for a dog that chews?
Wire crates are generally more chew-resistant than plastic, but a determined chewer can still damage them. For heavy chewers, consider a heavy-duty wire crate with thicker gauge wire or a plastic crate with reinforced edges. Always supervise your dog and provide appropriate chew toys.
How do I clean a wire vs plastic crate?
Wire crates are easy to spot clean, but urine can leak through the wire floor onto the floor below. Use a crate mat or tray. Plastic crates have a solid bottom pan that catches messes, making cleanup easier. Both can be wiped with mild soap and water.
