Soil Mixing Trays
Best Soil Mixing Trays for Potting and Repotting
7 picks compared
8 min read
ProductPickly is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks.
The short answerFor most gardeners the Drip Depot Green Garden Tray is the standout pick, since it is a plain one-piece tray built for the everyday job of mixing compost, blending amendments, and filling pots with no seams to leak. When your mix is loose and heavy, the deep 24.5 by 22 by 8 inch Garden Tidy Tray is our choice because its 8 inch walls keep everything contained. For indoor repotting the Luwint tray is aimed at succulents and houseplants, the Defemim one-piece tray is the pick for a permanent bench tray, and the Rainmae two-tray set adds shovels so you can start straight away. For spreading trays across several jobs, the five-pack is the value multipack and the Vesici three-pack is a smaller set. Choose by wall height, footprint, and how many trays you need rather than by price.
?How we pickedWe compare published specifications, safety certifications and thousands of verified owner reviews, and we do not physically test every unit. Read the full process in our review methodology.
Drip Depot Green Garden Tray for Potting, Planting and Soil Mixing
★★★★★ 4.6 / 5 Best overall
This is the tray we would reach for first, because it is a plain open one-piece body built for the everyday job of scooping compost, blending amendments, and filling pots without chasing spills across the bench. There is nothing clever to break here, and that simplicity is exactly why it works as a daily driver rather than a single-task tool.
Type Open low-sided trayBuild One-piece molded bodyJob Mixing, potting, plantingUse Bench or ground
- Open shape makes scooping and blending soil easy
- One-piece body has no seams to split or leak
- Neutral size suits most routine potting jobs
- Lower walls hold less than a deep tub for wet mixes
- Sold as a single tray, not a multipack
Best for: an everyday all-round mixing tray
Garden Tidy Tray Green, 24.5 x 22 x 8 One-Piece Potting Tray
★★★★★ 4.4 / 5 Best high-sided tub
When the mix is loose and you keep flicking it over the edge, this is the pick, since its 8 inch walls turn a shallow tray into a proper tub that contains a wet, heavy batch. The recycled one-piece plastic body is heavier duty than the thin bench trays, which suits repotting jobs that involve a lot of scooping and turning.
Size 24.5 x 22 x 8 inWall Deep 8 in sidesMaterial Recycled plasticBuild Sturdy one-piece
- Deep 8 in walls keep loose mix from spilling out
- Heavier one-piece body handles big scooping jobs
- Roomy footprint fits large pots and full bags of mix
- Too tall to slide under a low shelf or into a drawer
- Larger than a tabletop grower really needs
Best for: large repotting batches and wet, loose mixes
Luwint Garden Tidy Potting Tray for Indoor Transplanting
★★★★★ 4.3 / 5 Best for indoor use
For potting up succulents and houseplants at the kitchen table, this is our choice, because it is pitched as an indoor transplanting tray that keeps stray soil off the surface you are working on. It is the kind of tray you can set down inside, do a quick repot, and lift away without leaving a trail of potting mix behind.
Setting Indoor transplantingPlants Succulents, houseplantsType Open catch trayUse Tabletop potting
- Sized and pitched for indoor tabletop repotting
- Catches stray soil so cleanup is a quick lift-and-tip
- Good match for succulents and small houseplants
- Lighter duty than the deep outdoor tubs
- Not big enough for bulk soil batches
Best for: indoor succulent and houseplant repotting
Defemim Garden Tidy Tray, One-Piece 23 x 16.4 x 4.3 (Black)
★★★★★ 4.4 / 5 Best bench-size tray
If you want one tidy tray that lives on the potting bench, this is the pick, since its 23 by 16.4 inch footprint and mid-height 4.3 inch walls strike a workable balance between capacity and easy reach. Being one molded piece it doubles as a spot to seed, mix, grow on, and then store the empty pots when the job is done.
Size 23 x 16.4 x 4.3 inWall Mid-height 4.3 inBuild One-piece moldedRoles Seed, mix, grow, store
- Balanced size fits a standard potting bench
- Mid-height walls contain mix without blocking your reach
- One-piece body wipes clean and stacks empty
- Single tray only, so no spares for parallel jobs
- Walls are lower than the deep tub for very loose mixes
Best for: a permanent tray on the potting bench
Rainmae 2 Set Garden Tidy Trays with Shovels, 23 x 13.6 x 4.5
★★★★★ 4.3 / 5 Best tray-and-tool set
When you would rather not hunt for a scoop, this set is the pick, since it pairs two one-piece trays with shovels so you can start mixing the moment it arrives. Having a second tray means you can keep dry mix in one and work wet in the other, which is handy for anyone potting several plants in a session.
Size 23 x 13.6 x 4.5 inCount Set of 2 traysExtras Includes shovelsBuild One-piece body
- Two trays let you separate dry and wet mix
- Bundled shovels mean no hunting for a scoop
- Ready to use straight out of the box
- The included shovels are basic rather than heavy duty
- Two trays take more shelf space to store
Best for: starting out with trays and a scoop together
5 Pack Plant Potting Tray, 17 x 12 (Black)
★★★★★ 4.4 / 5 Best value multipack
For anyone who wants a tray in several spots at once, this is our value pick, because you get five compact 17 by 12 inch trays instead of one. The smaller footprint suits tabletop and windowsill potting, and having a stack of them means one for seeds, one for mixing, and a few to catch drips under pots.
Size 17 x 12 in eachCount Pack of 5Footprint Compact tabletopUse Seeding, mixing, drip catch
- Five trays cover several jobs and spots at once
- Compact size fits windowsills and small tables
- Stack flat for easy storage between uses
- Each tray is small for a full bag of mix
- Shallow trays are not made for deep, wet batches
Best for: spreading trays across seeds, mixing, and drip catching
Vesici 3 Pcs Garden Tidy Trays for Seeding and Growing
★★★★★ 4.2 / 5 Best small multipack
If five trays is more than you need but one is not enough, this three-pack is the pick, since it gives you a small set for seeding and growing on without the bulk of a larger multipack. It is a sensible middle ground for a balcony or a modest indoor setup where you still want a spare tray or two on hand.
Count Set of 3 traysType Open tidy traysJob Seeding and growingUse Balcony or indoor
- Three trays suit a small setup without excess
- Open shape works for seeding and light mixing
- Easier to store than a five-tray stack
- Fewer trays than the value five-pack for busy benches
- Listing does not state exact tray dimensions
Best for: a small set for balcony or indoor growing
A soil mixing tray does one job well: it keeps compost, potting mix, and amendments in one place while you blend them and fill pots, so the mess stays off your bench and out of the borders. The right one depends on how loose your mix is, how much you make at a time, and where you work. For a simple everyday tray the one-piece Drip Depot Green Garden Tray is our overall pick, with a deep tub, indoor trays, and multipacks below it for more specific needs.
Open tray vs high-sided tub vs foldable
The first choice is wall height. An open, low-sided tray like the Defemim Garden Tidy Tray is easy to reach into and ideal for routine potting on a bench, where you are scooping and turning small batches. A high-sided tub such as the 24.5 by 22 by 8 inch Garden Tidy Tray turns that shallow tray into a proper container that holds a big, loose, wet mix without flicking it over the edge. Foldable tubs are a third option that collapse flat for storage, but the rigid one-piece trays here sit more stably and have no seams to split, so unless storage space is your main worry a solid tray is the steadier pick.
Size for a bench vs a tabletop
Match the footprint to where you actually pot. On a potting bench or in the shed, a mid-size tray around 23 by 16 inches, like the Defemim, gives you room to work without swallowing the whole surface, and the deep tub suits bulk repotting. For a kitchen table, balcony, or windowsill, smaller is better: the compact 17 by 12 inch trays in the five-pack, or a modest set like the Vesici three-pack, are light to place and quick to lift away. The Luwint tray sits in the same tabletop camp, pitched squarely at indoor transplanting of succulents and houseplants.
Easy-clean and drainage
A tray you dread cleaning is a tray you stop using, so a smooth one-piece body matters. Molded trays like the Drip Depot and Defemim have no joints to trap mix, so a quick wipe or rinse empties them and they stack away clean. For mixing and potting you generally want a solid tray with no drainage holes, so mix and water stay contained rather than draining onto the bench. The same solid tray doubles as a drip catcher under pots later, and if you ever want it to drain you can add holes yourself, which is easier than trying to plug a tray that came pre-drilled.
Portability and storage
How a tray stores is as important as how it works. A single mid-size tray like the Defemim tucks onto a shelf and stacks with empty pots inside, while the tall 8 inch tub holds the most but is awkward to slide under a low shelf. Multipacks change the calculation: the five-pack and the Vesici three-pack stack flat and let you keep separate trays for seeds, mixing, and drip catching, which saves shuffling one tray between jobs. The Rainmae two-tray set adds shovels so the scoop travels with the trays. Think about how often you pot and how much space you have, and let that guide whether you want one sturdy tray or a small stack.
Questions people ask
What is a soil mixing tray actually for?
It is a shallow container that keeps potting mix, compost, and amendments in one place while you blend them and fill pots. Instead of scattering soil across a bench or table, you scoop, mix, and pot inside the tray, then tip the leftover mix back into the bag. A one-piece tray like the Drip Depot model does this with no seams to leak.
Should I choose an open tray or a high-sided tub?
An open, low-sided tray such as the Defemim is easy to reach into and suits routine potting on a bench. A high-sided tub like the 8 inch Garden Tidy Tray contains loose, wet mixes far better and holds a bigger batch, at the cost of being harder to store. Match the wall height to how loose and how large your typical mix is.
Are foldable soil trays worth it over a rigid one?
Foldable tubs collapse flat for storage, which helps if bench space is tight, but the rigid one-piece trays here are sturdier and sit flat and stable while you work. If you pot often and leave a tray out, a rigid model like the Defemim or Drip Depot is the simpler choice; a foldable tub mainly earns its place when storage room is the priority.
What size tray do I need for a bench versus a tabletop?
For a potting bench, a mid-size tray around 23 by 16 inches, like the Defemim, gives room to work without dominating the space. For a kitchen table or windowsill, the compact 17 by 12 inch trays in the five-pack or a smaller set from Vesici are easier to place and lift away when you are done.
How do I keep a tray from making a mess of loose mix?
Pick a tray with tall enough walls for how loose your mix is, and do not overfill it. Deep-sided models like the 24.5 by 22 by 8 inch tub keep dry, flyaway mixes contained, while shallow trays are fine for damp mixes that stay put. Working over the tray rather than beside it also keeps most stray soil where it belongs.
Can I use these trays for seed starting as well as mixing?
Yes. Many of these are sold as multi-role tidy trays, so the same body works for seeding, mixing, growing on, and storing empty pots. Multipacks such as the five-pack or the Vesici three-pack are handy here, since you can dedicate one tray to seeds and keep another for mixing without cross-contaminating.
Do soil mixing trays need drainage holes?
For mixing and potting you usually want a solid tray with no holes, so mix and water stay contained. If you plan to use a tray to grow on or to catch runoff under pots, a solid tray still works as a drip catcher. None of these picks are drilled from the factory, so you keep the mess in the tray unless you add holes yourself.
How did we choose these soil mixing trays?
We compared each tray on wall height, footprint, whether it comes as a single tray or a multipack, and the jobs it is pitched for, from bulk repotting to tabletop seeding. Every product shown is a real listing, and these are our chosen picks based on those specs rather than lab-tested claims.
The bottom lineSo which one?
The Drip Depot Green Garden Tray is our top choice for a single one-piece tray that handles everyday mixing and potting cleanly, and it covers the job for most gardeners. Step up to the deep 8 inch Garden Tidy Tray when you mix loose soil in bulk, choose the Luwint or Defemim trays for indoor and bench work, and reach for the five-pack or Vesici set when you want several trays for seeding and mixing at once. Let wall height, footprint, and tray count guide the pick, and any of these chosen trays will keep the mess in the tray and off your bench.
