Mattress Protectors
Best Mattress Protectors for Pillow Top Mattresses
7 picks compared
6 min read
ProductPickly is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks.
The short answerFor pillow top mattresses, the SafeRest Premium Cotton Top, Linenspa Premium Smooth Fabric, and PlushDeluxe Premium are top picks. They offer deep pockets, waterproof protection, and breathability.
?How we pickedWe compare published specifications, safety certifications and thousands of verified owner reviews, and we do not physically test every unit. Read the full process in our review methodology.
SafeRest Premium Cotton Top Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.5 / 5 Best Overall
This protector features a soft cotton terry surface and a waterproof membrane. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep, ideal for pillow tops. The cotton top adds breathability and comfort.
Pocket Depth Up to 18 inchesMaterial Cotton terry surface, TPU backingWaterproof YesCare Machine washable
- Breathable cotton top
- Deep pockets for thick mattresses
- Noiseless waterproof layer
- May feel warm for some sleepers
- Not as plush as quilted options
Linenspa Premium Smooth Fabric Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.4 / 5 Best Value
This protector offers a smooth, noiseless surface and a stretchable skirt. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The polyester top is breathable and comfortable.
Pocket Depth Up to 18 inchesMaterial Polyester smooth fabric, polyurethane backingWaterproof YesCare Machine washable
- Affordable price point
- Quiet and smooth
- Fits deep mattresses
- Less absorbent than cotton
- May slide if not fitted well
PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.6 / 5 Best for Hot Sleepers
This protector uses a bamboo-derived viscose surface that wicks moisture and stays cool. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The waterproof membrane is breathable.
Pocket Depth Up to 18 inchesMaterial Bamboo viscose blend, TPU backingWaterproof YesCare Machine washable
- Cooling bamboo surface
- Moisture-wicking
- Deep pockets
- Higher price
- Some may find it less soft
Best for: Best for Hot Sleepers
Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.3 / 5 Best Budget
This no-frills protector offers a waterproof barrier and a soft cotton surface. It fits mattresses up to 15 inches deep, which may not suit all pillow tops. It is simple and effective.
Pocket Depth Up to 15 inchesMaterial Cotton top, polyurethane backingWaterproof YesCare Machine washable
- Very affordable
- Breathable cotton
- Easy to care for
- May not fit extra-thick pillow tops
- Less durable over time
SureGuard Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.7 / 5 Best for Allergies
This protector is hypoallergenic and dust mite proof, with a cotton terry surface. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The waterproof layer is noiseless.
Pocket Depth Up to 18 inchesMaterial Cotton terry, polyurethane backingWaterproof YesCertifications GREENGUARD Gold, hypoallergenic
- Certified allergy protection
- Soft cotton surface
- Deep pockets
- Slightly heavier feel
- May be overkill for non-allergy users
Best for: Best for Allergies
Mattress Safe Premium Cotton Terry Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.6 / 5 Best for Extra Deep Pillow Tops
This protector fits mattresses up to 22 inches deep, ideal for very thick pillow tops. It has a soft cotton terry surface and a waterproof membrane. The skirt is elasticized for a secure fit.
Pocket Depth Up to 22 inchesMaterial Cotton terry, polyurethane backingWaterproof YesCare Machine washable
- Fits extra deep mattresses
- Soft and absorbent
- Secure elastic skirt
- Premium price
- May be too bulky for standard mattresses
Best for: Best for Extra Deep Pillow Tops
Sleep Defense System Waterproof Mattress Protector
★★★★★ 4.5 / 5 Best for Kids and Pets
This protector is designed for heavy-duty use, with a soft cotton top and a thick waterproof layer. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The surface is resistant to stains and odors.
Pocket Depth Up to 18 inchesMaterial Cotton top, polyurethane backingWaterproof YesGuarantee 10-year warranty
- Durable for active use
- Stain and odor resistant
- Deep pockets
- May feel less breathable
- Heavier material
Best for: Best for Kids and Pets
We compared specs like pocket depth, material, and waterproofing. We also considered owner feedback on comfort and durability.
What to Look For in a Pillow Top Protector
Pillow top mattresses are thicker than standard ones. Measure your mattress depth before buying. Look for a protector with a deep pocket, typically 18 inches or more. Check the material for breathability and waterproofing. A cotton or bamboo surface adds comfort. A polyurethane backing provides waterproof protection without noise.
Waterproof vs Water-Resistant
Waterproof protectors block all liquids, ideal for spills and accidents. Water-resistant ones may repel light moisture but not full submersion. For pillow tops, waterproof is safer to protect the padding. Look for a membrane like TPU or polyurethane. These are noiseless and breathable.
Material and Breathability
Cotton terry is soft and absorbent, but may retain heat. Bamboo viscose is cooling and moisture-wicking. Polyester is smooth and budget-friendly but less breathable. Consider your sleeping temperature. Hot sleepers should choose bamboo or cotton with cooling properties.
Fit and Installation
A secure fit prevents bunching and sliding. Elastic skirts should hug the mattress corners. Deep pockets accommodate extra thickness. Some protectors have a zipper for full encasement, but those are less common. Read owner feedback on fit for specific mattress brands.
Questions people ask
How deep should a mattress protector be for a pillow top?
Most pillow tops add 2 to 4 inches to mattress height. Measure your total depth. Look for a protector with a pocket depth of at least 18 inches. Some extra-thick models go up to 22 inches.
Can I use a regular mattress protector on a pillow top?
You can, but it may not fit properly. Regular protectors often have 14 inch pockets. They can slip off or tear. It is better to choose a deep pocket protector.
Is a waterproof mattress protector necessary for a pillow top?
Yes, because pillow tops are prone to stains and moisture damage. Waterproofing protects the padding and extends mattress life. Look for a breathable waterproof membrane.
Will a mattress protector make my pillow top feel different?
A thin protector may not change feel much. Thick quilted ones can add cushioning. Choose a smooth, low-profile design to preserve the pillow top feel.
How do I wash a mattress protector for a pillow top?
Most are machine washable. Use cold or warm water and a gentle cycle. Tumble dry low or air dry. Check the care label for specific instructions.
What is the best material for a pillow top mattress protector?
Cotton terry is soft and absorbent. Bamboo is cooling and moisture-wicking. Polyester is smooth and affordable. Choose based on your comfort and temperature needs.
Are bamboo mattress protectors worth it?
Bamboo protectors offer natural cooling and moisture control. They are often more breathable than polyester. If you sleep hot, they can be worth the extra cost.
Can a mattress protector prevent dust mites?
Yes, if it is hypoallergenic and has a tight weave. Look for certifications like GREENGUARD Gold. These protectors create a barrier against allergens.
Do mattress protectors fit all pillow top sizes?
No, sizes vary. Always check the pocket depth and dimensions. Some brands offer specific sizes for deep mattresses. Measure your mattress before buying.
Is a mattress protector the same as a mattress pad?
No. A protector is thin and waterproof. A pad adds cushioning and comfort. Some protectors combine both features, but they serve different purposes.
The bottom lineSo which one?
For most pillow top owners, the SafeRest Premium Cotton Top offers the best balance of fit, comfort, and protection. If you sleep hot, choose the PlushDeluxe Bamboo. Budget shoppers can rely on the Utopia Bedding, provided their mattress is not too thick.
